Published 2 November 2026 · By Jatin Dua, Broker of Record, RE/MAX Quantum Realty
What's Your Home Worth Right Now?
Get a free AI-powered price range for your property in under 90 seconds, based on recent GTA comparable sales. No name or address required.
Get My Free Estimate →
Analyze an investment property by rebuilding its net operating income from the rent roll and real expenses, dividing by a market cap rate to test the price, then sizing the loan by DSCR. In an illustrative $5 million, 16-unit GTA building at a 4.31% cap rate, borrowing leaves a cash-on-cash return of only about 1.3% to 1.6%.
This guide is for investors with $1 million to $10 million who want to judge a rental building the way a lender and a careful buyer would, before they make an offer. You will get the full method, a worked $5 million GTA apartment example with every number shown, and the checks that prove or break the numbers in 2027.
How do you analyze an investment property step by step?
Every income property, from a fourplex to a plaza, is judged with the same six questions. I run them in this order with my clients, because each answer feeds the next one.
- What does it really earn? Start from the rent roll, the list of every unit, tenant, rent and lease date. Add parking, laundry and storage income.
- What does it really cost to run? Property tax, insurance, utilities, repairs, management and a reserve for big items like roofs and boilers.
- What is the NOI? Net operating income is income minus operating costs, before mortgage payments and income tax.
- What is it worth? Divide NOI by the cap rate the market pays for that kind of building.
- How much will a lender give you? Lenders limit the loan by loan-to-value (LTV) and by the debt service coverage ratio (DSCR).
- What do you earn on your cash? Cash flow after the mortgage, divided by all the cash you put in, is your cash-on-cash return.
If you want the theory behind cap rates and DSCR in more depth, I wrote a separate explainer on how commercial property is valued. Here, we put the method to work.
How do you calculate NOI on a rental building?
Take a hypothetical 16-unit walk-up apartment building in the GTA, asking $5,000,000. That is $312,500 per door (price divided by units). Everything below is illustrative: I picked round, realistic-looking inputs to teach the method, not to describe a real building. Your own building will have its own numbers, and you should rebuild this table from its actual bills.
| Line (illustrative 16-unit building) | Assumption | Annual amount |
|---|---|---|
| Rent | 16 units x $2,000 a month | $384,000 |
| Parking and laundry | $500 a month | $6,000 |
| Vacancy and bad debt | 4% of rent | -$15,360 |
| Effective gross income | $374,640 | |
| Property tax | assumed | -$40,000 |
| Insurance | assumed | -$16,000 |
| Heat, hydro and water | assumed | -$38,000 |
| Repairs and maintenance | $1,500 per unit | -$24,000 |
| Superintendent and cleaning | assumed | -$15,000 |
| Property management | 4% of effective gross income | -$14,986 |
| Accounting, legal, admin | assumed | -$5,000 |
| Replacement reserve | $400 per unit | -$6,400 |
| Net operating income (NOI) | expenses = 42.5% of income | $215,254 |
| Cap rate at $5,000,000 | NOI / price | 4.31% |
Source: illustrative example; arithmetic checked. Vacancy assumption is close to the 3.85% Toronto multifamily vacancy Lee & Associates reported for Q3 2026.
Two habits matter here. First, I include management and a reserve even if the owner self-manages, because a lender and your next buyer will. Second, I use the rent tenants pay today, not the rent the building “could” get. You can test both numbers in my rental cash flow calculator.
What cap rate should a GTA apartment building sell at in 2027?
A cap rate (capitalization rate) is NOI divided by price. A lower cap rate means a higher price for each dollar of income. Published benchmarks for late 2026 differ, and they differ for good reasons:
- Lee & Associates put the average Toronto multifamily cap rate at 4.21% in Q3 2026, with an average sale price of $392,524 per unit and asking rent of $2,222 per unit.
- Avison Young’s Q3 2026 benchmark for high-density urban multifamily was 4.55%, as reported by Canadian Mortgage Professional in October 2026.
- CBRE’s national average across all property types was 6.56% in Q3 2026. Industrial, retail and office usually trade at higher cap rates than apartments.
The figures differ because each source tracks a different set of buildings and method. Treat them as ranges, not a price list. The bigger risk sits in the NOI itself.
The seller’s NOI versus your NOI
Suppose the listing shows the same building at a 4.96% cap rate. The seller assumed 1% vacancy and left out management and the reserve, so their NOI is $248,160. If a 4.96% cap rate is what you need to pay $5,000,000, then on the honest NOI of $215,254 the building is worth about $4,337,000 at that same cap rate. Same building, a $663,000 gap, created by three lines of a spreadsheet. This is why I rebuild every seller’s numbers from scratch.
To see what your own cash buys and how the cash flow compares across building types, use the calculator below; it is set to $5 million but you can change every number.
Loading the investment calculator…
How much can you borrow against a $5 million apartment building?
Lenders cap the loan two ways. LTV is the loan as a share of value. DSCR is NOI divided by annual mortgage payments; a DSCR of 1.20 means the building earns $1.20 for every $1 of debt payment. Whichever limit is lower wins, and at today’s cap rates DSCR usually wins.
| Illustrative loan | Rate / amortization | Minimum DSCR | Loan | LTV | Yearly payments | Cash flow |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Conventional | 5.25% / 25 years | 1.20 (assumed) | $2,508,431 | 50.2% | $179,378 | $35,876 |
| CMHC-insured (MLI Standard) | 4.40% / 40 years | 1.10 | $3,700,982 | 74.0% | $195,685 | $19,569 |
| Private-insured, from 1 Feb 2027, 5-year term | 4.40% / 40 years (assumed) | 1.15 | $3,540,069 | 70.8% | $187,177 | $28,077 |
Source: illustrative example with semi-annual compounding. Rates sit inside the ranges derived from the 3.60% five-year Government of Canada yield (2 Oct 2026) plus Avison Young Q3 2026 spreads; DSCR minimums for insured loans from CMHC and Finance Canada. Insurance premiums are not included.
Note what happened: neither insured option reached its 85% LTV limit, because the 4.31% cap rate cannot carry that much debt. Insurance premiums would also be added to the loan; each 1% premium on a $3.7 million loan adds about $37,000. My post on commercial mortgage rates in 2027 explains where those rates come from.
What cash-on-cash return does a $5 million building earn?
Cash-on-cash return is yearly cash flow after the mortgage, divided by all the cash you put in. “All the cash” means the down payment plus land transfer tax plus closing costs. On a $5,000,000 apartment building, Ontario land transfer tax is $96,475. Inside the City of Toronto you also pay the municipal tax, for a total of $192,950. I added an illustrative $50,000 for legal, appraisal, building condition report, environmental report and lender fees. My guide to land transfer tax on commercial property shows the brackets.
- Conventional, in Toronto: $2,734,519 of cash for $35,876 of cash flow, about 1.3%.
- CMHC-insured, in Toronto: $1,541,968 of cash for $19,569, about 1.3%.
- Private-insured, in Toronto: $1,702,881 of cash for $28,077, about 1.6%.
- All cash, in Toronto: $5,242,950 for $215,254 of NOI, about 4.1%.
Mortgage payments also repay principal. In year one that is roughly $50,000 on the conventional loan and about $35,000 on either insured loan in this example. That builds equity, but it is not cash in your pocket. The honest reading: at a 4.3% cap rate and 4.4% to 5.25% debt, borrowing adds almost nothing to the yearly return. The case for this building rests on rent growth on turnover, principal paydown and long-term value, not on cash flow.
What happens to the numbers if rates rise 1%?
Run the same loans one point higher, as you would at a renewal five years out. The conventional loan’s DSCR falls to 1.09 and cash flow drops to $18,169. The CMHC loan’s DSCR falls to 0.96, so the building no longer covers its payments by about $9,000 a year. The private-insured loan lands at roughly break-even.
This is not a remote scenario. The Bank of Canada raised its policy rate to 2.50% on 28 October 2026 and said a further increase could be needed. Its next decision is 9 December 2026. Fixed commercial rates follow bond yields, which rose through the fall. Always run a stress case before you sign.
How do rent control and the rent roll change your analysis?
In Ontario, most units first occupied before 15 November 2018 are limited to the provincial guideline, which is 1.9% for 2027. Units first occupied after that date are exempt from the guideline. In an older walk-up, that means income grows slowly while costs can rise faster.
The upside usually comes on turnover, when a unit can be re-rented at market. Compare the rent roll with current asking rents; Lee & Associates reported $2,222 per unit in Q3 2026 for Toronto. A building at $2,000 average may have room. But do not pay today for rent you have not earned, and do not assume tenants will leave. Renovation-based evictions carry legal rules and, in Toronto, a licence requirement.
What due diligence proves the numbers?
Your analysis is only a hypothesis until the documents confirm it. Make your offer conditional on reviewing them. Lenders typically want an appraisal, an environmental assessment, a building condition assessment and a title search, according to BDC’s guidance on commercial property financing.
- Rent roll and leases: match every rent to a lease and to bank deposits.
- Estoppel certificates: signed tenant statements confirming rent, deposits and lease terms.
- Trailing 12 months (T12): the last year of actual income and expenses, with utility bills and the tax bill.
- Building condition assessment (BCA): an engineer’s report on roof, boiler, windows, balconies and electrical, with a cost schedule.
- Phase 1 Environmental Site Assessment (ESA): a records and site review for contamination risk, such as old oil tanks.
- Legal status: confirm every unit is legal and the use matches zoning.
My full apartment building due diligence checklist goes line by line.
Build your own NOI before you look at the seller’s cap rate, and size the loan from DSCR, not from the LTV a lender advertises. In this example, the honest numbers say the building is a long-term equity play with thin cash flow. That can still be a good purchase for the right investor, but only if you buy it knowing that, at a price your own spreadsheet supports.
A low cap rate plus a long amortization can look fine in year one and fail at renewal. If the building only works at today’s rate with a 40-year amortization, a 1% rise can push DSCR below 1.0. Keep a cash reserve and test a higher renewal rate before you firm up.
What to do next
- Ask for the rent roll, the T12 and the tax bill before you discuss price.
- Rebuild the NOI with vacancy, management and a reserve, even if the seller left them out.
- Size the loan three ways, conventional, CMHC and the private-insured option from 1 February 2027, and stress each at 1% higher.
- Write the offer conditional on financing, a BCA, a Phase 1 ESA and estoppels. Have your lawyer and accountant review the structure.
- Use the calculator above to compare building types, then book a call with me to walk through a specific building you are considering.
Need help with this? Talk to me.
I’m Jatin Dua, Broker of Record at RE/MAX Quantum Realty, and I’m the best agent to do this kind of work for you in Toronto and across the GTA. Over $100 million in GTA sales and 100+ families helped sell. Feel free to contact me any time: call or text 833-330-1925 or email [email protected].
Frequently asked questions
How do you analyze an investment property in Canada?
Start with net operating income: rent and other income, minus vacancy and all operating costs, before mortgage payments. Divide NOI by the market cap rate to test the price, size the loan by LTV and DSCR, then divide cash flow by all the cash you put in. In 2027, run a stress test at a rate 1% higher, and confirm every number with the rent roll, T12, building condition report and environmental report.
What is a good cap rate for an apartment building in Toronto in 2027?
Recent Toronto apartment trades point to roughly 4.2% to 4.6%. Lee & Associates reported a 4.21% average Toronto multifamily cap rate in Q3 2026, and Avison Young benchmarked high-density urban multifamily at 4.55%. A “good” cap rate depends on the building: older stock with deferred repairs should trade higher, while newer buildings exempt from rent control can trade lower. Always apply the cap rate to your own NOI, not the seller’s.
What is the difference between NOI and cash flow?
NOI is income minus operating costs before any mortgage payment; cash flow is what is left after the mortgage. In my illustrative $5 million GTA building for 2027, NOI is $215,254, but after a conventional loan’s $179,378 of yearly payments, cash flow is $35,876. Lenders and buyers value a building on NOI, while your personal return depends on cash flow, principal paydown and value change.
What DSCR do lenders require for a rental building in Canada?
CMHC sets a 1.10 minimum for standard rental housing, and the new private-insured rules from 1 February 2027 require 1.15 on a five-year term or 1.10 on a ten-year term. Conventional lenders set their own minimums and commonly ask for more; my 2027 examples assume 1.20. DSCR is NOI divided by yearly mortgage payments, and it often limits the loan more than the advertised LTV.
How much cash do I need to buy a $5 million apartment building?
In my illustrative 2027 example, about $1.5 million to $2.7 million in Toronto, depending on financing. That covers the down payment, $192,950 of combined Ontario and Toronto land transfer tax and about $50,000 of other closing costs. A CMHC-insured loan needed the least cash; a conventional loan needed the most because DSCR limited it to about 50% of the price.
What is cash-on-cash return in real estate?
Cash-on-cash return is yearly cash flow after mortgage payments divided by the total cash you invested. For a $5 million GTA apartment building at a 4.31% cap rate in 2027, my illustrative example returns about 1.3% to 1.6% with financing and about 4.1% all cash. It ignores principal paydown, tax and value change, so read it alongside those.
Should I trust the cap rate on a commercial listing?
No, treat it as the seller’s marketing number until you rebuild the NOI yourself. Listings often assume very low vacancy and leave out management and a replacement reserve. In my illustrative 2027 GTA example, those three changes moved the same building from a 4.96% to a 4.31% cap rate, which at the seller’s cap rate is a value gap of about $663,000.
Does rent control affect the value of an Ontario apartment building?
Yes. Units first occupied before 15 November 2018 are generally limited to the provincial guideline, which is 1.9% for 2027, so income on long-term tenancies grows slowly. Value upside comes mainly when units turn over and are re-rented at market. Buildings first occupied after that date are exempt from the guideline, which is one reason newer rentals can trade at lower cap rates.
What reports should I get before buying an apartment building in Ontario?
At minimum, get the rent roll and leases, tenant estoppel certificates, the last 12 months of income and expenses, a building condition assessment, a Phase 1 Environmental Site Assessment, an appraisal and a title search. Lenders usually require several of these anyway. Make your 2027 offer conditional on reviewing them, and have your lawyer confirm every unit is legal.
Sources
- Altus Group: Toronto commercial real estate market update, Q3 2026
- Lee & Associates: Toronto multifamily market report, Q3 2026 (PDF)
- CBRE: Canadian cap rates and investment insights, Q3 2026
- Canadian Mortgage Professional: What persistently high bond yields could mean for the commercial mortgage market (15 Oct 2026)
- Department of Finance Canada: Mortgage insurance rule changes to support missing middle housing (5 Nov 2026)
- City of Toronto: Municipal land transfer tax rates and fees
- Bank of Canada: Policy rate raised to 2.5% (28 Oct 2026)
- BDC: How to get approved for commercial real estate financing
Related reading
- How to Invest $5 Million in GTA Real Estate (2027): Your Real Options
- What $5 Million Buys in GTA Real Estate in 2027: Houses, Buildings, Plazas and Land
- A $5 Million House or a $5 Million Apartment Building in Toronto? The 2027 Math
- Commercial vs Residential Real Estate Investment in the GTA (2027)
About the author — Jatin Dua, Toronto and GTA real estate broker
I am Jatin Dua, Broker of Record and co-founder of RE/MAX Quantum Realty Inc., Brokerage, Unit 101, 799 The Queensway, Toronto. I work with buyers and sellers across Toronto and the GTA and have helped more than 100 families sell. Four-plus years of active GTA transactions and over $100 million in sales volume.
Reach me at [email protected] or 833-330-1925, or book a call.
More from the library
- Your Landlord Is Blocking Your Practice Sale. Here Is the Case That Ends It.
- Buying Development Land in the GTA (2027): What an Investor Is Really Buying
- Buying a Private School in Ontario: The Notice of Intention, a New BSID and What You Inherit
- Humber Bay Shores vs Roncesvalles: New Build or Old Brick?
- Buying a Driving School in Ontario: MTO Licence, Instructors, Cars and Curriculum
- DW Lofts, 160 Bedford Rd: Eight Big Suites Between Yorkville and the Annex
