RE/MAX Quantum RealtyHome valueContact

Your Landlord Is Blocking Your Practice Sale. Here Is the Case That Ends It.

Published 12 November 2026 · By Jatin Dua, Broker of Record, RE/MAX Quantum Realty

Short answer: in Ontario, a commercial landlord generally cannot unreasonably withhold consent to an assignment of your lease, and if yours is stalling, demanding concessions, or burying you in document requests, the Court of Appeal has already said that is not allowed. The case is Rabin v 2490918 Ontario Inc., 2023 ONCA 49, and it is about exactly this situation: a dentist trying to sell his practice.

What's Your Home Worth Right Now?

Get a free AI-powered price range for your property in under 90 seconds, based on recent GTA comparable sales. No name or address required.

Get My Free Estimate →

If you are a dentist whose sale is hostage to a landlord’s signature, read this and then send it to your lawyer.

Why this happens to dentists more than anyone else

A dental practice sale almost always needs the lease to go with it. The buyer is not buying a filing cabinet; they are buying a location, a patient base that lives near that location, and several hundred thousand dollars of operatories plumbed into that specific floor. Without the lease, there is nothing to buy.

Landlords know this. The moment they learn you are selling, they also learn that their consent has become the most valuable thing in the transaction. A landlord who has wanted a demolition clause for ten years, or a better guarantee, or a rent bump, suddenly has leverage they never had before. Some of them use it.

What most selling dentists do not know is how little the law lets them get away with.

What happened in Rabin

Dr. Rabin was a dentist of about 70 who had been a tenant in the same building since roughly 1977. He wanted to semi-retire and sell his practice to two younger dentists. That required assigning his lease.

His lease gave the landlord 15 days to respond to his written notice of intent to assign. The landlord did not respond in 15 days.

Twenty-two days after the initial request, the landlord’s lawyer came back with terms. Consent would be given only if:

  • the incoming principal provided a personal guarantee;
  • the outgoing principal — Dr. Rabin — kept his personal guarantee in place; and
  • the lease was amended to add a demolition clause on 24 months’ notice.

Dr. Rabin rejected that. The landlord’s lawyer then emailed to say consent was denied, and asked for an extensive list of documents and information about the assignee.

Dr. Rabin applied to the court under the Commercial Tenancies Act. He lost at first instance: the application judge found he had waived the 15-day requirement and had not shown that consent was refused or unreasonably withheld.

What the Court of Appeal held

The Court of Appeal reversed, and it did so on several independent grounds. Each one is worth knowing, because each is a thing landlords routinely do.

Missing the deadline was itself an unreasonable withholding of consent. Not a technicality to be cured later — the failure to respond within the 15 days the lease specified was, on its own, unreasonable. The Court noted the landlord had no reasonable excuse, having known the request was coming and having read the clause.

The waiver finding did not survive. Neither party had argued waiver; the Court declined to let it stand.

The denial email was an unreasonable refusal.

Asking for more information long after the deadline was unreasonable. You cannot sit on a request, blow the deadline, and then reset the clock by demanding a due diligence package.

Conditioning consent on a demolition clause was unreasonable, because the clause benefited only the landlord. The Court put it in a line worth memorising: “A conditional consent, is not a consent.”

The appeal was allowed and the landlord was ordered to give consent, permitting the assignment.

The law behind it

Section 23 of the Commercial Tenancies Act implies into a commercial lease a standard that the landlord may not unreasonably withhold consent to an assignment — unless the lease expressly provides otherwise. The Act does not define “unreasonably,” so ordinary meaning and the common law fill the gap, which is what Rabin contributes to.

Section 23(2) is the mechanism: the tenant can apply to the court for a determination of whether consent was unreasonably withheld.

Two cautions. The first is that “unless the lease expressly provides otherwise” is doing real work — a lease can be drafted to give the landlord an absolute discretion, and if yours does, this analysis changes. The second is that every case turns on its own facts. Rabin is powerful because the landlord’s conduct was egregious across several dimensions at once.

If your sale is being blocked right now

  1. Find the consent clause and the deadline. How many days does the landlord have, and from what trigger? Diarise it the day you serve notice.
  2. Serve written notice properly, in the form and to the address the lease requires. Sloppy notice is the one defence worth giving a landlord.
  3. Keep the clock. Record the date of your request and every response. In Rabin, the dates were the case.
  4. Do not negotiate against yourself. If the landlord’s “consent” arrives with new conditions attached that benefit the landlord, that is the pattern the Court of Appeal addressed.
  5. Give them what a reasonable landlord is entitled to, promptly — the assignee’s financial information, their covenant, their intended use. Reasonableness runs both ways, and a landlord with a genuine credit concern about your buyer is in a much stronger position.
  6. Get your lawyer to look at s. 23(2) early, not after six months of emails. The remedy exists and it works.

If you are signing a dental lease today

Everything above is a cure. This is the prevention, and it costs nothing at the negotiating table:

  • A fixed, short response period for consent to assign, with deemed consent if the landlord does not respond in time. That single provision would have ended Rabin before it started.
  • Agreement that consent will not be unreasonably withheld, conditioned or delayed — all three words.
  • A pre-agreed, closed list of what the landlord may ask about an assignee, so the request cannot become infinite.
  • A release of the outgoing principal’s personal guarantee on a permitted assignment.
  • No demolition clause. If the landlord insists on one, a long notice period, a hard outside date before which it cannot be exercised, and compensation for unamortised leasehold improvements.

A dentist signs one or two leases in a career and sells one practice. The clauses that decide whether that sale is easy or impossible are negotiated years before anyone is thinking about it.


If you are selling a practice in the GTA and the lease is the obstacle, or you are about to sign one and want the assignment language right the first time, that is the part of this I can help with.

Sources

  • Rabin v 2490918 Ontario Inc., 2023 ONCA 49.
  • Commercial Tenancies Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. L.7, s. 23.

This is general information from a commercial real estate broker, not legal advice. Lease language varies and so do outcomes — have your own lawyer read your lease.

More from the library

Browse every article

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Call or text 833-330-1925
Scroll to Top