RE/MAX Quantum RealtyHome valueContact

Owning Property Directly vs REITs in Canada (2027): Which Fits a Large Investor?

Published 2 November 2026 · By Jatin Dua, Broker of Record, RE/MAX Quantum Realty

What's Your Home Worth Right Now?

Get a free AI-powered price range for your property in under 90 seconds, based on recent GTA comparable sales. No name or address required.

Get My Free Estimate →
Older brick walk-up apartment building on a quiet Toronto street in autumn (illustrative)

By Jatin Dua · Broker of Record, RE/MAX Quantum Realty · Updated 2 November 2026 · 11 min read — Direct property or REITs for $1M to $10M in 2027: control, liquidity, tax, NAV discounts and a worked $5M example.

Short answer

Own buildings directly if you want control, can hold for years and will do the work of a landlord; choose public REITs if you want daily liquidity and no management. In late 2026 Canadian REITs averaged a 4.7% yield, while Toronto apartment cap rates near 4.2% and loans above 5% left leveraged buildings with thin cash flow.

This guide is for investors with roughly $1 million to $10 million who are deciding between owning buildings themselves and buying units of real estate investment trusts (REITs). You will get a plain comparison of control, cost, tax and risk, an illustrative $5 million example with the arithmetic shown, and a clear way to decide which one fits you in 2027.

Should a large investor own property directly or buy REITs?

It depends on what you want the money to do. Direct ownership gives you control, leverage you choose, and the chance to add value by fixing a building, raising rents on turnover or redeveloping land. REITs give you a share in large portfolios that you can buy or sell in minutes, with a professional manager and no tenant calls.

For most of my clients with $5 million, the honest answer is that they are really choosing between two jobs. Owning a building is a part-time business. Owning REIT units is a portfolio decision. If you do not want the business, the building will not suit you, no matter how good the numbers look.

I should be clear about my role. I am a licensed real estate broker. I help investors buy and sell property directly. I do not sell REIT units, fund units or any other security, and nothing here is a recommendation to buy one.

What is a REIT in Canada, and how does it work?

A REIT is a trust that owns income-producing real estate, such as apartments, plazas, warehouses or seniors housing, and passes most of its income through to its unitholders. Public REITs trade on a stock exchange like shares.

The tax rules are what make the structure work. The Canada Revenue Agency taxes most publicly traded trusts much like corporations under the specified investment flow-through (SIFT) rules, but a trust that qualifies as a real estate investment trust for the year is excluded from that tax. To qualify, the trust must pass asset and revenue tests. In plain terms, most of its assets must be Canadian real property and most of its income must come from rents, mortgage interest and gains on real property.

How are REIT distributions taxed?

Each part of a distribution keeps its character in your hands. Part may be ordinary income, part may be a capital gain, and part may be a return of capital. A return of capital is not taxed when you receive it, but it lowers your adjusted cost base, so you pay more capital gains tax when you sell the units. Confirm the treatment for your own account with your accountant.

What does $5 million buy directly, compared with REIT units?

Here is an illustrative example. It is not a real building, and every number is an assumption I have stated so you can change it.

The direct purchase (illustrative)

  • Price: $8,000,000 for an older Toronto apartment building.
  • Cap rate: 4.25%. A cap rate is the building’s net operating income (NOI) divided by its price. NOI is rent and other income minus vacancy and operating costs, before mortgage payments. Lee & Associates reported an average Toronto multifamily cap rate of 4.21% for Q3 2026, so 4.25% is close to that.
  • NOI: $8,000,000 × 4.25% = $340,000 a year.
  • Loan: a conventional mortgage at 5.25% with a 30-year amortization. That rate sits inside the roughly 4.9% to 5.6% range implied for conventional apartment loans in October 2026 (5-year bond yield plus lender spreads).
  • Lender test: a debt service coverage ratio (DSCR) of 1.20. DSCR is NOI divided by yearly mortgage payments. At 1.20, payments can be at most $283,333 a year, which supports a loan of about $4,275,000, or about 53% of the price.

The cash you put in is the $3,725,000 down payment, plus $312,950 of Ontario and Toronto land transfer tax on an $8 million apartment building, plus an assumed $75,000 for legal, lender, appraisal and inspection costs. That totals $4,112,950, leaving about $887,000 of your $5 million as a reserve.

The mortgage payment is about $23,607 a month, or $283,280 a year. Cash flow is $340,000 minus $283,280, which is $56,720 a year. That is a cash-on-cash return of about 1.38% on the $4,112,950 invested. The loan principal also falls by about $60,280 in year one, which is equity you build but cannot spend.

The REIT purchase (illustrative)

Canadian REITs had a weighted average distribution yield of 4.7% at the end of August 2026, according to figures presented at a RealREIT conference. If you put $5,000,000 into a basket of REITs yielding that average, you would receive about $235,000 a year before tax. Distributions are not fixed. A REIT can cut them, and unit prices move every day.

The two numbers are not a fair race. The REIT yield already reflects the REIT’s own debt and its fees. The building’s return depends on rent growth, the units you turn over, the repairs you control and the price when you sell. My point is narrower: with Toronto apartment cap rates near 4% and conventional loans above 5%, borrowing does not boost cash flow today. A direct buyer is paid for work and patience, not for leverage.

To see what your own cash buys and how the cash flow compares across building types, use the calculator below. It is set to $5 million, but you can change every number.

Loading the investment calculator…

How do direct property and REITs compare side by side?

This table compares the two on the points that matter most to a large private investor. It describes how the structures generally work, not any specific REIT or building.

Factor Owning a building directly Owning public REIT units
Control You choose rents, repairs, financing and when to sell None. Management and the board decide
Liquidity Selling usually takes months Units trade daily on the exchange
Leverage You pick the loan, within lender rules on loan-to-value and DSCR Set by the REIT. You cannot change it
Cost to buy in Land transfer tax, legal, lender and inspection fees Trading commission. No land transfer tax
Diversification Often one or two buildings Many properties, often many cities
Price you pay Negotiated for the building itself Market price, which can sit above or below the value of the buildings
Time needed Real, even with a property manager Close to none
Value-add Possible: renovation, turnover, added units Only through the manager

Source: CRA SIFT rules and RSM Canada, The ABCs of REITs (June 2024); Ontario and Toronto land transfer tax rates as of November 2026.

Why do Canadian REITs trade below the value of their buildings?

Many public REITs have traded at a discount to their net asset value (NAV), meaning the unit price is lower than the appraised value of the buildings minus the debt. In September 2026 the total market value of Canadian REITs was about $76 billion, the same as a year earlier and well below a record of $101 billion. Their trailing 12-month price return was negative 1% and their total return, including distributions, was 4%.

Private buyers have noticed. Four apartment REITs have been taken private recently, and in the InterRent and Minto Apartment REIT deals unitholders received premiums of 35% and 32% over the trading price. Buying a whole REIT can be cheaper than buying its buildings one at a time.

For you, this cuts both ways. A discount can mean you buy buildings through a REIT for less than they would cost directly. It also shows that the public market can value the same buildings well below what private buyers pay, for years at a time.

What are the risks of private REITs and real estate funds?

Private and non-traded real estate funds do not trade on an exchange. You usually get your money back only through the fund’s own redemption process, and a fund can limit or stop redemptions. By March 2026, Bloomberg counted about $30 billion locked in Canadian private real estate funds that had halted or curbed redemptions or distributions, close to 40% of the roughly $80 billion invested in such funds.

Watch out

Anyone who sells you units in a REIT, fund, pool or syndication in Ontario generally must be registered with the Ontario Securities Commission, or rely on a specific exemption. Before you hand over money, look the person and the firm up in the OSC’s registrant search or the National Registration Search, and read what category they are registered in. Registration does not mean the product is good or that you cannot lose money. It means someone accountable is on the hook for suitability.

A real estate agent who offers you a piece of a “deal” or fund is a red flag unless that person is also registered to sell securities. My work stays on the property side: helping you buy a building in your own name or your company’s name.

How do costs and taxes differ when you buy and sell?

Buying a building costs real money up front. On a $5 million apartment building or commercial property in Toronto, Ontario and Toronto land transfer tax together come to $192,950. Outside Toronto there is no municipal tax, so the same building pays only the $96,475 Ontario tax. Buying REIT units on an exchange carries no land transfer tax.

When you sell, half of a capital gain is taxable for both buildings and REIT units. The proposed increase in the inclusion rate was cancelled in March 2025. A building can also bring other items at sale, such as recapture of depreciation you claimed, which my guide to rental income tax and Form T776 explains. Whether you hold the property personally, in a company or in a trust changes the answer, so confirm with your accountant. My post on buying investment property in a corporation covers the main trade-offs.

Who should own buildings directly, and who should stick with REITs?

Direct ownership tends to suit you if:

  • you have time, or will pay a good property manager and still review the numbers monthly;
  • you can hold for many years and do not need the cash back on short notice;
  • you want to add value through repairs, turnover or added units; and
  • you are comfortable with one or two large assets rather than many small ones.

REITs tend to suit you if you want daily liquidity, broad diversification and no management at all, or if your amount is too small to buy a building with a sensible reserve.

My take

Many of my investor clients end up doing both: they buy one well-chosen building they can understand and manage, and keep other money in liquid investments chosen with their own registered adviser. The mistake I see is buying a building to chase a yield that a REIT already pays, without wanting the work. If you buy directly, buy a building where you can see a specific way to improve its income, and underwrite it with conservative rents and today’s rates.

What to do next

  1. Decide how much of your capital must stay liquid for the next five years, and keep that out of any building purchase.
  2. If you are looking at REITs or funds, check every seller’s registration with the OSC before you invest, and ask how and when you can get your money out.
  3. If you are looking at buildings, run a few properties through my cap rate calculator and read how commercial property is valued so the terms are familiar.
  4. Talk to your accountant about whether to buy personally, through a holding company or in a trust.
  5. Use the $5 million calculator above for your own numbers, then book a call with me to walk through a specific building and its rent roll.

Need help with this? Talk to me.

I’m Jatin Dua, Broker of Record at RE/MAX Quantum Realty, and I’m the best agent to do this kind of work for you in Toronto and across the GTA. Over $100 million in GTA sales and 100+ families helped sell. Feel free to contact me any time: call or text 833-330-1925 or email [email protected].

Frequently asked questions

Is it better to buy real estate or REITs in Canada?

Neither is better for everyone in 2027. Owning a building directly in Canada gives you control, leverage you choose and room to add value, but it takes time and money to buy and sell. Public REITs give daily liquidity and diversification with no management work, but you cannot control the buildings or the debt. Many large investors use both.

How are REIT distributions taxed in Canada?

REIT distributions in Canada are taxed according to what they are made of. Part may be ordinary income, part a capital gain and part a return of capital. Return of capital is not taxed when received, but it lowers your adjusted cost base, so more capital gains tax is due when you sell the units. Confirm your own situation with your accountant.

Do you pay land transfer tax when you buy REIT units?

No. Buying units of a public REIT on a stock exchange in Canada does not trigger Ontario or Toronto land transfer tax. Buying a building directly does: on a $5 million apartment building in Toronto the two taxes together are $192,950 as of November 2026, and outside Toronto the Ontario tax alone is $96,475.

Why are Canadian REITs trading below net asset value in 2026?

Many Canadian REITs traded below net asset value in 2026 because public markets valued their buildings below what private buyers would pay. Total Canadian REIT market value was about $76 billion in September 2026, against a record of $101 billion. Several apartment REITs were taken private at premiums of 30% or more to their trading prices.

Can a private real estate fund stop me from taking my money out?

Yes. Private and non-traded real estate funds in Canada can limit or suspend redemptions under their own terms. By March 2026, Bloomberg counted about $30 billion locked in Canadian private real estate funds that had halted or curbed redemptions or distributions. Read the redemption terms before you invest and assume you may not get money back quickly.

How do I check if someone selling a real estate investment is registered in Ontario?

Use the Ontario Securities Commission’s registrant search or the National Registration Search run by the Canadian Securities Administrators. Search both the person and the firm, and check the category they are registered in. In Ontario, people selling REIT, fund or syndication units generally must be registered or rely on an exemption. Registration does not guarantee you will not lose money.

How much cash do you need to buy an apartment building directly in Toronto?

It depends on the loan, but in late 2026 lenders sized conventional apartment loans by debt coverage, which often keeps them well below 75% of the price. In my illustrative $8 million Toronto example, the loan was about 53% of the price, and the down payment, land transfer tax and fees came to about $4.1 million. Insured financing can lower that.

What cash return does a Toronto apartment building make compared with a REIT?

With Toronto apartment cap rates near 4.2% and conventional loans above 5% in late 2026, a leveraged building’s cash-on-cash return can be low, about 1.4% in my illustrative example. Canadian REITs averaged a 4.7% distribution yield in August 2026. The building’s return also depends on rent growth, principal paydown and the eventual sale price.

Are REITs more liquid than owning property in Canada?

Yes, public REITs are far more liquid. Their units trade on a stock exchange every business day, so you can usually sell within minutes, though the price may be lower than you hoped. Selling a building in Canada usually takes months, from listing through conditions and closing, and private real estate funds may restrict redemptions.

Sources

Related reading

About the author — Jatin Dua, Toronto and GTA real estate broker

I am Jatin Dua, Broker of Record and co-founder of RE/MAX Quantum Realty Inc., Brokerage, Unit 101, 799 The Queensway, Toronto. I work with buyers and sellers across Toronto and the GTA and have helped more than 100 families sell. Four-plus years of active GTA transactions and over $100 million in sales volume.

Reach me at [email protected] or 833-330-1925, or book a call.

Please read this. General information current as at 2 November 2026. It is not legal, tax, accounting, mortgage or financial advice. I am a registered real estate broker, not a lawyer, accountant or mortgage agent. Market figures are TRREB MLS data accessed through REALM or come from the sources linked above; they describe past sales and are not a forecast. Rules, rates and programs change, so confirm details with the official source or a licensed professional before you rely on them.

Free toolWhat’s being built near me?Look up every rezoning, site plan and condo application filed near any Toronto address, with free alerts.

More from the library

Browse every article

Call or text 833-330-1925
Scroll to Top